The REAL reason Rory McIlroy called off his divorce - and part THAT golf journalist played. Insiders tell what happened behind closed doors after ­'irretrievably broken' shock, wife's steely move and the rumours that just won't go away

The REAL reason Rory McIlroy called off his divorce - and part THAT golf journalist played. Insiders tell what happened behind closed doors after ­'irretrievably broken' shock, wife's steely move and the rumours that just won't go away
By: dailymail Posted On: April 10, 2026 View: 33

Earlier this week, on a balmy Tuesday evening in Augusta, Georgia, golfing superstar Rory McIlroy played host at the annual Champions Dinner, which brings together former Masters winners ahead of the tournament's start yesterday.

As defending champion, it was the 36-year-old's job to curate the menu for the meal, held in the storied Library at Augusta National's clubhouse.

Yet for most onlookers, it was not the catering – or even speculation about McIlroy's chances of defending his title – that drew attention.

Instead, there was only one question on everyone's lips: would his wife, Erica, be by his side?

After all, only two years ago, in the aftermath of the 2024 Masters, McIlroy stunned the golfing world by announcing his intention to divorce, before dramatically reversing course just a month later.

That startling about-turn, the Daily Mail now understands, came after McIlroy came to the realisation that splitting from Erica, 38, might severely limit the time he spent with their five-year-old daughter, Poppy.

'When he began thinking about co-parenting Poppy, and how often he would get to see her,' says one source who knows the couple well, 'he began to realise he couldn't have Poppy on tour. He wouldn't be co-parenting at all, but seeing his daughter once in a blue moon when he was back in the country. He couldn't handle that.'

In the event, Erica was indeed beaming by her husband's side on Tuesday night, radiant in a chic white minidress as the couple posed for photographs ahead of the dinner.

Clad in traditional white ‘caddy’ jumpsuits, the McIlroys looked every inch the picture-perfect unit – laughing, chatting and lingering together
Two years ago, in the aftermath of the 2024 Masters, Rory McIlroy stunned the golfing world by announcing his intention to divorce before dramatically reversing course just a month later

The following day, in one of the Masters' most cherished traditions, she and Poppy joined McIlroy for Family Day, when partners and children step into the spotlight to play three holes of golf.

Clad in traditional white 'caddy' jumpsuits, the McIlroys looked every inch the picture-perfect unit – laughing, chatting and lingering together between shots as Poppy clapped enthusiastically at her father's play.

To the casual observer, it was a portrait of domestic harmony – as well as a determinedly united front.

For just 24 hours earlier had seen the publication of a revealing new book about McIlroy – one that pulls few punches when it comes to his personal life.

Written by American sports journalist Alan Shipnuck, Rory: The Heartache And Triumph Of Golf's Most Human Superstar offers a detailed examination of both his professional brilliance and his emotional volatility.

Not least among its talking points are long-running unsubstantiated rumours that he had become involved with 39-year-old American golf reporter Amanda Balionis.

For his part, Shipnuck is firm in his conclusion that the relationship was not romantic, although he concedes that, while writing the book, the question of whether there had been a romance accounted for '90 per cent' of the curiosity surrounding his subject. Either way, the timing of the book's publication will not have gone unnoticed by a couple acutely aware of how closely they are watched.

McIlroy is a man whose private life has long played out in parallel with his public triumphs.

He famously broke the heart of his first love, Holly Sweeney – whom he met as a teenager in his native Holywood, near Belfast – after he fell for Danish tennis star Caroline Wozniacki.

Within two years, McIlroy had proposed to Wozniacki, presenting her with a £98,000 eight-carat diamond ring during a New Year's trip to Sydney Harbour in 2013.

It was a grand gesture that seemed to promise a fairytale ending, but which instead unravelled with brutal efficiency.

In May 2014, just days after wedding invitations had been sent, McIlroy ended the engagement in a three-minute phone call.

At first he described the split as mutual, later revealing he 'wasn't ready for all that marriage entails'.

By then, he had already met Erica Stoll.

A poised and undeniably attractive blonde, Stoll, then 24, was working for America's Professional Golfing Association (PGA) when their paths first crossed at the 2012 Ryder Cup. She famously helped arrange a police escort after McIlroy overslept and risked missing his tee time.

Although their relationship did not begin until after his split from Wozniacki, Shipnuck suggests there was little doubt that McIlroy had been captivated early on. 'He was throwing every ounce of game he had at Erica,' one colleague recalls. 'It was not subtle...'

Rory McIlroy and Caroline Wozniacki attend the 2013 US Golf Writers Dinner in Georgia
When Ilroy's daughter Poppy was just three, then came that bombshell announcement he had filed for divorce, citing an ‘irretrievably broken’ union

By 2015, they had gone public. Engagement followed that same year and in 2017 they married at the majestic Ashford Castle in County Mayo.

The couple subsequently settled into a £7 million mansion in an exclusive gated community in Florida, and in August 2020 welcomed daughter Poppy.

Certainly, there is no question McIlroy is a devoted father.

At a press conference earlier this week, when asked what had brought him the most joy away from the game over the past year, his answer was immediate. 'Watching my daughter grow up,' he replied. 'I think Poppy is like a mini Erica. It's like living with two of them… which is great a lot of the time.'

Yet even fatherhood did not seem enough to stabilise the marriage. In May 2024, when Poppy was just three, came that bombshell announcement that McIlroy had filed for divorce, citing an 'irretrievably broken' union.

He instructed prominent Florida lawyer Thomas Sasser – the same man who had overseen Tiger Woods's high-profile divorce from Elin Nordegren.

There had been no obvious warning signs – publicly at least. But behind the scenes, rumours had been gathering pace, particularly surrounding McIlroy's friendship with Balionis.

And then, just as suddenly as the divorce had been announced came the handbrake turn.

By mid-June, McIlroy had filed a Notice of Voluntary Dismissal of the divorce petition, and made a point of saying that the two had come to a mutual agreement to stay in the marriage.

'Erica and I have realised that our best future was as a family together,' he said in an interview. 'Thankfully, we have resolved our differences and look forward to a new beginning.'

Privately, however, the reality may have been more complicated, according to one source who knows the couple. 'Erica was served divorce papers on May 13, given 20 days to respond… and didn't,' they revealed. 'She didn't hire a lawyer and she didn't speak to anyone… because she knew him well enough to know he wouldn't actually leave. Erica is seen as this delicate flower, but she's got a steely streak.'

A year later, Erica stood beside her husband as he secured the coveted green jacket.

Her presence, along with Poppy's, was widely interpreted as a deliberate public signal that the marriage was strong.

Three months later, the couple relocated from Florida to a vast renovated mansion on the exclusive Wentworth estate in Surrey.

'You don't spend £10million building a house and uproot your life to Surrey if you're simply going through the motions,' says one observer.

Others, however, remain sceptical about the relationship.

And since then, the pair have kept a notably low profile.

Erica has attended just one tournament this year – February's Genesis Invitational in California.

'The marriage certainly isn't all fairies and rainbows... he's only interested in golf,' one insider told the Daily Mail.

Those close to Erica, however, paint a more nuanced picture.

'She worked in the golf world before she married into it,' says a friend. 'She understands what it takes.

'And actually, I think they are both extremely committed to making it work. I would not be surprised to hear that they're planning to expand their family.'

Rory himself paid tribute to Erica's 'calming presence', telling the Daily Mail last year: 'She is a low-key person, but she brings a level of normality to everything. She never wants to be the centre of attention and is always comfortable in the background.

'It is great having someone like that and someone who knows what it is all about, having been around the game.'

Even so, this week will not have been easy.

Quite aside from the lingering presence of Amanda Balionis at Augusta in her professional capacity, there are also the more provocative claims within Shipnuck's book.

One imagines that once this Masters tournament is over – whether or not McIlroy wins – Erica will be more than ready to retreat into relative anonymity

Shipnuck references McIlroy's 'ribald streak' and the persistent rumours surrounding his love life, while also appearing to criticise Erica's reluctance to step into the public eye.

Startlingly, he also includes an interview with McIlroy's 2014 Team Europe Ryder Cup captain Paul McGinley, who claims McIlroy's 'big personality' means that despite his praise for his wife's 'low-key' persona he would have been better off married to someone who appeared to love the limelight more.

He added. 'It can't be easy being Rory's wife. I'm sure it's not easy for her because she's quiet by nature'.

Few would dispute that latter sentiment, and one imagines that once this Masters tournament is over – whether or not McIlroy wins – Erica will be more than ready to retreat into relative anonymity again.

As for McIlroy, it's useful to recall a telling observation he once made about his golfing prowess. 'For whatever reason,' he reflected, 'I seem to play very good golf whenever I have a lot of stuff going on.'

The bittersweet reality may be that if he fails to defend his title this week, it may at least mean that peace prevails at home.

So what's become of the flirtatious interviewer at heart of gossip?

By Daniel Bates

Sports journalist Amanda Balionis interviewing Rory McIlroy as part of CBS's golf coverage

Smiling broadly and stepping out this week at the Masters, Amanda Balionis has the relaxed, confident air of a woman who is exactly where she wants to be in life.

Two years after unsubstantiated rumours of an affair with champion golfer Rory McIlroy, the US TV sports presenter's career is blossoming. And her love life is, too – having revealed a new man in her life.

As part of TV network CBS's golf team, Balionis is covering the tournament in Augusta. And as CBS is the official network for the competition, it's possible the 39-year-old will interview McIlroy if the Northern Irishman retains the title.

It was, of course, another interview with Balionis in 2024 that fuelled speculation about relations between the golfer and the attractive interviewer, known for her flirtatious on-air style and skill at drawing out often taciturn sportsmen.

When McIlroy failed to mention his wife Erica Stoll – the mother of their daughter – during the chat at the Wells Fargo tournament which coincided with US Mother's Day, onlookers were bemused.

A day later, when he filed for divorce from his wife of seven years, declaring the union 'irretrievably broken', bemusement turned to shock.

Looking for a reason for the unprompted announcement, observers noted the apparent closeness between Balionis and McIlroy during their interview.

Days later the Daily Mail broke the news of an alleged affair between the pair after McIlroy was seen picking up a takeaway in Balionis's name in San Diego, California, where the presenter has a home.

In the wake of the unsubstantiated claims, it would have been easy for Balionis to become the 'fall girl'. But she refused to let the embarrassment derail her career.

In April last year, McIlroy finally won the Masters, securing his first Green Jacket in 17 years of trying. Less than a year after their rumoured liaison, Balionis interviewed him again.

If she had any nerves about meeting him face to face in the full glare of the cameras, she didn't show it. And it is this unflappable demeanour, say insiders, that has helped her survive and thrive.

According to sports writer and author April Tod, who has covered the golf circuit for years, Balionis has 'learned a lesson' from the episode.

She said: 'It is a very male-orientated world. People will quite easily pull you down. That shows how determined she was to brush everything under the carpet and prove she's good.'

Balionis has slapped down her critics numerous times on social media and has a strong network of supporters within the game. CBS has shown new faith in her, too, and last year sent her to cover tennis at Wimbledon and the NFL.

In 2022, she married Bryn Renner, a former American footballer, but they split in 2024, the same year as her alleged affair with McIlroy.

She found love again in early 2025 with Peter Engen, an estate agent from Nantucket, Massachusetts, and posted a picture of him with her family in April. In January this year, she removed any doubt they were an item with an Instagram photo showing them cuddled up together.

We won't know until Sunday how McIlroy will fare at the Masters, but for now at least, with a new man and flourishing career Balionis looks like a winner.

Read this on dailymail
  Contact Us
  Follow Us
Site Map
Get Site Map
  About

Read the latest local and international news from trusted sources in one place.